Keyed Car Repair Cost: Scratch Depth, Panel Count, and Repaint Price

You walked back to your car and found a long, deliberate line scratched down the side. Before you phone a body shop, you can work out whether this is a quick buff or a multi-panel repaint. That one distinction drives most of your keyed car repair cost.

Vandalism feels personal, and not knowing the price makes it worse. Two things decide most of the bill: how deep the key went and how many panels it crossed.

This guide gives you a three-step check you can do in a parking lot. By the end, you'll know which repair tier your damage sits in, what pushes the price up, and how to get a real number from your own photos.

How Much Does It Cost to Fix a Keyed Car? The Short Answer

It depends on your repair tier. A keyed car can need a polish you barely notice paying for, or a full side repaint with blending. The work and the cost climb at each step.

The four repair tiers at a glance

The table shows relative cost, not dollar figures. Shop rates, paint colour and location move the real number. To get yours, you need an estimate based on your actual damage. That's covered at the end.

Why two keyed cars can cost very differently

Picture two cars keyed on the same night. One has a faint line across a single door that disappears when wet. The other has a scratch through to primer, running from the front fender to the rear quarter panel.

The first might need only a polish. The second means repainting several panels and blending the colour so the side doesn't look patchy. Same cause, completely different job.

Step 1: Check How Deep the Key Scratch Goes

Depth decides whether the paint can be saved or has to be replaced. Car paint is built in layers: clear coat on top, colour (base) coat beneath, then primer, then the metal or plastic panel. The deeper the key went, the more layers the shop has to rebuild.

For scuffs, chips and other paint damage that isn't keying, see the wider guide to car paint repair costs for scratches, chips and scuffs.

Clear coat only: the fingernail test and what "buffs out" means

Run a fingernail gently across the scratch. If your nail glides over without catching, the damage is probably limited to the clear coat.

That's the best case. A clear-coat scratch can often be polished down until it disappears or becomes hard to see. A splash of water is another quick check: if the line nearly vanishes while wet, it's likely shallow.

Into the colour coat: when you see a lighter line but no grey or white

If your nail catches slightly and the scratch shows a lighter or duller shade of your car's colour, the key reached the colour coat. Polishing alone usually won't remove it.

Short, narrow scratches at this depth are touch-up candidates. Long ones often push you toward a panel repaint, because a long touch-up line tends to stay visible.

Down to primer: grey or white showing

Grey or white at the bottom of the scratch means the key cut through the clear and colour coats to the primer. Both layers above have to be rebuilt.

Keying marks are usually long, so at this depth you're almost always looking at a panel repaint, not a touch-up.

Bare metal or plastic: shiny silver or black base, plus rust risk on metal

Shiny silver means bare metal. Black or dark grey on a bumper usually means bare plastic.

Exposed steel can start to rust if left alone, so don't sit on this one for months. Bare-substrate scratches need the full rebuild: prep, primer, colour and clear.

Step 2: Count the Panels the Key Crossed

Most people skip this step, yet it's usually the biggest cost multiplier with keyed damage. Vandals rarely stop at a panel edge, and each panel the scratch touches is, in effect, its own paint job.

One panel: the most contained repaint

If the scratch stays on one door or one fender, the shop has a single panel to prep, paint and finish. That's the most contained repaint.

Even then, the shop may lightly blend colour into neighbouring panels so the shade matches. More on that in Step 3.

Two adjacent panels

When a scratch crosses a panel gap, say from the front door onto the rear door, both panels need work. Depth on each panel matters as much as length.

The guide to repairing a scratch across two panels covers this case in detail.

A full side: door-to-door-to-quarter-panel keying and why it multiplies cost

Full-side keying is the classic vandalism pattern: one long line from the front fender, across both doors, onto the rear quarter panel. That's three or four panels on one side.

Every panel needs prep and paint, and the panels at each end may need blending too. Labour, materials and booth time all scale with panel count. That's why full-side keying costs so much more than a single scratched door.

Step 3: Factor In Panel Material, Location, and Paint Type

Depth and panel count give you your tier. Three details decide where you sit within it.

Plastic bumper vs metal door or quarter panel

Bumpers are usually plastic, and painting plastic needs its own prep steps. Bumpers are also often removable, while a quarter panel is part of the body and has to be painted on the car.

If the key caught your bumper, the guide to estimating bumper scratch repair costs from photos explains what changes.

Scratches over body lines and edges

A scratch on a flat, open area is the easiest to repair cleanly. One that runs over a crease, body line or panel edge takes longer, because those contours need careful shaping and finishing.

Edges also show paint mismatches more clearly, so the shop may extend the repair area.

Metallic, pearl, and tri-coat paint: why colour matching and blending add labour

Solid colours are the simplest to match. Metallic and pearl paints contain particles that reflect light differently depending on how the paint is sprayed, so a fresh panel can look off next to an older one.

Shops hide that by blending the new colour into neighbouring panels. Tri-coat finishes add another layer on top. More stages and more blending mean more labour.

Buff, Touch-Up, or Repaint? Match Your Damage to the Right Fix

Combine Steps 1 and 2 to find your tier: depth on the left, panel count across the top.

Then adjust with Step 3: metallic or pearl paint, body lines and edges push you toward the higher end of your tier.

When a polish or buff is enough

If your nail doesn't catch and the line fades when wet, a polish is the realistic fix, even if the scratch runs the length of the car. A long, shallow keying mark takes more labour to buff than a short one, but it still costs far less than a repaint.

When touch-up paint makes sense, and when it looks worse

Touch-up works best on short, narrow scratches into the colour coat, ideally on a solid colour. It fills the groove and protects the layers underneath.

On a long keying line, touch-up often looks like what it is: a painted-on stripe. On metallic paint, the shade rarely sits right. If you'll see it every day, a repaint usually looks better.

When only a repaint and blend will look right

Primer or bare substrate showing, a long scratch through the colour coat, or damage across several panels: that's repaint territory. Blending into neighbouring panels stops the repaired section from standing out.

Not sure which row you're in? Upload a photo of the damage to see your estimate. The itemised breakdown lists each damaged area separately, so you can see whether you're paying for one panel or four.

Can You Fix a Keyed Car Yourself?

Sometimes. Your answer from Step 1 decides it.

DIY that's realistic (clear-coat-only marks)

If the scratch passes the fingernail test, careful hand polishing with a polishing compound can reduce or remove it. Work slowly, test a small area first, and stop if the line isn't improving.

Where DIY usually backfires (deep, long, or multi-panel scratches)

Rattle-can paint and touch-up pens on a long keying mark often leave ridges, colour mismatches or overspray. Fixing a failed DIY job adds work for the shop.

Once colour coat, primer or bare metal shows along most of a panel, or across several panels, a professional repaint is usually the cleaner and cheaper path.

Keyed Car Insurance: Claim It or Pay Out of Pocket?

Whether keying is covered, and what claiming costs you, depends on your policy and insurer. Don't assume either way.

What to check in your own policy before deciding

Check whether your policy covers vandalism, what your deductible is for that type of claim, and what your insurer asks you to provide, such as a police report or photos within a set time. Your policy documents or your insurer can confirm all of this for your situation.

Using an independent estimate to compare against your deductible and the insurer's figure

An independent first estimate gives you a reference point. If the likely repair cost sits close to your deductible, paying yourself may be simpler. If it's well above, a claim may be worth it.

Read more on when a photo estimate helps with an insurance claim. If the insurer's figure looks short, here's how to challenge an insurance estimate that seems too low.

How to Photograph Keyed Damage for a Faster, Tighter Estimate

Your photos need to show exactly what you just checked. Clear shots let an estimate pin down depth and panel count instead of guessing.

One wide shot per side, then close-ups of each affected panel

Start with a wide shot of the whole damaged side so the full length of the scratch is visible. Then take a close-up of every panel the key crossed, so three damaged panels never get counted as one.

Angled light to show depth; include where the scratch crosses panel gaps

Shoot with light coming from an angle, not straight on, so the groove casts a shadow and shows its depth. Get a clear shot wherever the scratch crosses a panel gap, because that's where panel count gets decided.

For the full shot list, see how to photograph car damage for an accurate estimate.

Frequently Asked Questions

Can a keyed car scratch be buffed out?

Yes, if the scratch is only in the clear coat. If your fingernail doesn't catch and the line fades when wet, a polish can often remove or hide it. If you see a lighter colour, grey, white or bare metal, polishing won't be enough.

Does insurance cover a keyed car?

It depends on your policy. Check whether vandalism is covered, what your deductible is and what documentation your insurer requires. Your insurer can confirm this for your policy.

Do I need to repaint the whole side if my car was keyed?

Not always. Only the panels the scratch touched need repainting, plus possible blending into neighbouring panels for a colour match. But if the key ran from fender to quarter panel, that can add up to most of the side.

Get Your Keyed Car Repair Estimate From a Photo

Your keyed car repair cost comes down to depth, panel count, and your panel material and paint. You now know your likely tier. The next step is a number based on your actual damage.

Upload your photos and you'll get an itemised breakdown for each damaged area, with parts and labour listed separately, plus a PDF you can take to a shop or your insurer. Sign in and you get one free full report per month. Otherwise, one-time passes run from $9.99 to $14.99, with no subscription. See the options on the pricing page.

Treat it as your fast first estimate, not a final or insurance-approved quote. Photos can't show hidden damage. Before you upload, you can read what a photo estimate can and can't see.

Get My Estimate